What Is the Preservation of Evidence?
The preservation of evidence is a judicial procedure in which the court establishes and records the existing state of affairs that may subsequently change or disappear, most commonly through an on-site inspection and expert examination. It is governed by Articles 272 to 276 of the Civil Procedure Act. A motion for the preservation of evidence may be filed before the commencement of civil proceedings, as well as during such proceedings.
In a large number of civil-law relationships, the parties find it necessary to initiate proceedings for the preservation of evidence in order to establish the current state of affairs and secure evidence for potential future civil litigation between them.
Over the past few months, a large number of clients have approached our law firm in connection with various types of legal proceedings involving claims for damages, the rectification of construction defects and other matters requiring the preservation of evidence in order to establish the actual state of affairs.
The procedure for the preservation of evidence is governed by the provisions of the Civil Procedure Act (Official Gazette Nos. 53/1991, 91/1992, 112/1999, 129/2000, 88/2001, 117/2003, 88/2005, 2/2007, 96/2008, 84/2008, 123/2008, 57/2011, 25/2013, 89/2014, 70/2019, 80/2022, 114/2022, 155/2023, 146/2025) and may be conducted before the commencement of civil proceedings.
In practice, proceedings for the preservation of evidence are conducted in connection with various types of disputes, most commonly disputes involving contractual or non-contractual liability and claims for damages arising from a situation in which one of the contracting parties fails to fulfil its contractual obligations.
Recently, we initiated proceedings for damages on behalf of a foreign national. The other party had leased him a plot at a campsite for the commercial rental of a mobile home but had failed to provide the agreed electricity, water and other utility connections, nor had it arranged the surrounding area and access to the campsite as stipulated in the agreement. Through the preservation of evidence procedure, we established the actual state of affairs, providing the basis for termination of the agreement and a claim for loss of profit.
In this particular case, the preservation of evidence procedure established the existing state of affairs and provided the legal and evidentiary basis for initiating proceedings to terminate the concluded agreement and claim compensation for lost profits.
The preservation of evidence procedure establishes the actual state of affairs, and the parties cannot subsequently dispute the facts established through it, as it is an official judicial procedure in which both parties participate.
For another client, we initiated proceedings for the preservation of evidence to establish defects in a villa constructed by a contractor under a turnkey contract. Some of the works had been carried out unprofessionally, while others had not been carried out at all, resulting in moisture penetrating the building and making urgent remedial works necessary.
Before the remedial works commenced, a court-appointed expert established the actual condition of the property within the preservation of evidence proceedings. Only after this had been completed was the client able to proceed with the necessary repairs. The client could then claim the repair costs and legal costs, including the costs of the preservation of evidence proceedings, in subsequent damages proceedings against the contractor.
In order to proceed with urgent remedial works, it is first necessary to establish the actual condition of the property through a court-appointed expert within preservation of evidence proceedings. Only then can the remedial works be carried out.
Once the preservation of evidence proceedings have been completed, the client may initiate damages proceedings against the contractor. In those proceedings, the client will be able to successfully claim compensation for the damage resulting from the established defects, the costs of repairing those defects through third parties, as well as the court costs incurred, including the costs of the preservation of evidence proceedings.
The preservation of evidence is most commonly required in construction disputes, investment project implementation and other disputes involving claims for damages.
The Law Office of Luka Mrkić represents clients in preservation of evidence proceedings and in subsequent civil litigation arising from them.
What is the preservation of evidence?
A judicial procedure in which the court establishes and records a state of affairs that may subsequently change or disappear, most commonly through an on-site inspection and expert examination. The procedure is governed by Articles 272 to 276 of the Civil Procedure Act.
When should proceedings for the preservation of evidence be initiated?
When there is a risk that evidence may no longer be available or that obtaining it at a later stage may become more difficult, for example, before urgent remedial works are carried out to rectify construction defects. A motion may be filed either before civil proceedings commence or during such proceedings.
Who establishes the actual state of affairs?
The court, usually with the assistance of a court-appointed expert. Both parties are invited to participate in the proceedings.
Can I repair the damage before the preservation of evidence proceedings take place?
It is advisable not to do so. Once the repairs have been completed, it may no longer be possible to establish the condition of the property as it existed beforehand, or to determine the full extent of the damage.
Can I claim the costs of the preservation of evidence proceedings from the other party?
Such costs may be claimed in subsequent damages proceedings as part of the legal costs of the proceedings.
Author: Luka Mrkić, Attorney-at-Law